A Difficult Float Trip down the Manambolo River

Little Water and High Heat Make for a Difficult Experience

October 2022

Click on any image for a larger view;
Contact garya at this domain if you would like the high quality image for printing

We spent the night in Tana at the Ikopa Hotel. The hotel was mediocre, the food was mediocre, and the service was mediocre. We had a blinking light overhead all night long, which we couldn't remove and no matter what we changed, something was blinking.

Lova and Caesar met us early in the morning. Caesar was driving a different vehicle, a Nissan 4WD with higher clearance. The vehicle was stuffed, as it had camping gear and food for the four days of our trip. Lova drove some at first when we were on good roads, so Caesar could sleep. Apparently we had a really long day ahead with some tough driving.

As we were leaving town we passed a transportation hub crowded with many different colored minibuses. Lova told us there was a 46% literacy rate in Madagascar, where literacy meand "read and understand numbers." Because many people can't read, the busses going to different rural communities are painted different colors.

Manambolo R Tana
Typical small town Madagascar traffic

We passed a gated community which Lova said was where wealthy Pakastini families lived. He said they kept to themselves and didn't mix much with the rest of the people.

We learned the Indian Mina birds were introduced to control locusts and crickets, and probably caused the extinction of several local species.

Manambolo R Mining Gold
Mining Gold

The countryside had few trees; it was mostly dry grassland. Lova said the few trees left were Tapia, because they are fire-resistant. They are all that is left in some places after over 50 years of slash and burn agriculture.

Manambolo R Erosion
Manambolo R Erosion PA210238
Photo by Dona

Erosion

Somewhere along the way, about the time we left the pavement, we picked up another guy who rode with all the gear in the back. Tovo's job was to point the way when we got lost.

Manambolo R Picnic PA210236
Picnic Lunch
Photo by Dona

Manambolo R Rice Paddies
Rice Paddies

It was slow going, even when we were still on the pavement, due to the poor condition of the road. After we left the pavement it was tough driving. The road was heavily rutted and muddy, with steep ups and downs. There were big boulders in some of the creeks we forded, with a steep approach down into the creek and a steep exit on the other side.

Manambolo R Road
Road

Manambolo R Road
Manambolo R Road

Manambolo R

We came to the village of Beambiaty, where they raise oranges. Place names in Madagascar are descriptive. "Be" means "a lot of." "ambiaty" means oranges. Because of the orange trees, there is no burning in the town and the orange groves, so alongside the road we found a wider variety of vegetation and with it, boatloads of chameleons. In a creek bottom we saw a Yellow-Billed Kite, a Red Fody, and a Pied Crow. In another sheltered, undisturbed place we saw a Red-Tailed Vanga, Grey-Headed Lovebirds, and a Madagascar Bee-eater. We also relearned the word for white guys, "Vazama."

Manambolo R Chameleon Jeweled
Jeweled Chameleon
Manambolo R Chameleon Oustalets
Photo by Dona

Oustalet's Chameleon
Manambolo R Flower Xxx Red
Flower Xxx Red
Photo by Dona

Manambolo R Beambiaty
Manambolo R Beambiaty Gary Sid PA210246
Gary and Sid
Photo by Dona

Beambiaty

Manambolo R Beambiaty Pano
Beambiaty

Manambolo R Road
Photo by Dona
Manambolo R Road

Road

Manambolo R Road Zebu
Zebu hauling firewood

Everywhere we went we saw deliberately set grass fires and massive erosion.

Manambolo R Burning Grass
Burning Grass
Photo by Dona

Manambolo R Erosion
Photo by Dona
Manambolo R Erosion
Photo by Dona

Erosion

Manambolo R Road
Photo by Dona
Looking Down on the Road
Manambolo R Road
Heading into the "Road"

Manambolo R Road
Yea! We might make it without getting stuck...

After we left Beambiaty, the road deteriorated further. We got lost several times and had to backtrack, despite Tovo's guidance.

As we were heading down to an impassable-looking creek bottom I looked across to see a fully-loaded freight truck headed towards us. How could you navigate this road in something like that?

Manambolo R Creek Xing
We barely made it across this creek.
Manambolo R Truck
A fully-loaded freight truck???

Manambolo R
Grey-headed Lovebirds
Photo by Dona
Manambolo R Bird Fork Tailed Drongo
Fork Tailed Drongo
Photo by Dona

We were headed for a spot on a plateau above the village of Ankavandra, which is down on the Manambolo River. The trucks were hauling freight too and from the village. They have good rice production at the village, but no easy way to ship it out. So they haul it up to the top of the plateau, and the freight trucks haul it to Tana from there. I asked Lova why they didn't ship it down the river, and he said the road to Bekopaka at the take-out was even worse. Since the villagers have no good way to ship the rice, they get a poor price for it.

Manambolo R Flower Xxx Red
Flower Xxx Red
Photo by Dona
Manambolo R Flower Xxx Orange
Flower Xxx Orange
Photo by Dona

It was dark when we finally arrived at our destination on top of the plateau above the village of Ankavandra at about 18:30. We were met by our guides, cooks, and porters. The porters may be guides weren't guiding on this trip; they rotate the guides so everyone who is qualified has a chance to earn the higher pay. But they may also be less-qualified workers from the village. They had some sort of dinner cooking on a fire, but we were too tired to eat much of anything. A storm was brewing so the guides scrambled to get our tents, and theirs, set up. The storm arrived in a hurry, and we dove into our tents.

The tents were not the best, some cheap Chinese copies with weak poles not really suited for stormy weather. I spent half the night lying down with one arm braced and a fist against the tent wall to prevent it from collapsing.

Manambolo R Camp
Camp

But morning eventually came, and with it a clearing and a tremendous view, albeit impeded by the usual smoke. A pair of Pied Crows was soaring around camp looking for leftovers.

Manambolo R
Manambolo River from Camp at End of Road

Manambolo R
Manambolo R Tree
Photo by Sid

Manambolo R

The top of the plateau is 600 - 800 m (~2500') above the river and the village. We had a quick breakfast and started hiking down as soon as we could, hoping to avoid the worst of the mid-day heat.

Manambolo R Hike Down
Starting the Hike Down
Manambolo R Hike Down

We only had to carry our day packs with water and snacks; the guides and porters carried our other bags (we had one each) and the camping gear and food we would need for the trip. The had no special bags or rigs for carrying the gear; they just grabbed what they could and somehow made it work.

Manambolo R Hike Down
Who needs Big Backpacks
or Fancy Hiking Shoes?
Manambolo R Hike Down

I was hoping to see some interesting animals and birds on the way down, but we didn't see much. We did find a frog near the trail. There was a beautiful waterfall off to the south.

Manambolo R Bird Pied Crow
Pied Crow
Manambolo R Frog Xxx
Xxx Frog

Manambolo R Waterfall
Manambolo R Waterfall

Waterfall

Manambolo R Hike Down

It took us 4½ hours to make it to Ankavandra. The last hour was pretty hot. Once we got off the plateau we hiked a ways on flatter ground, then forded a small stream. A bit more walking across dried out fields and we were in the town of Ankavandra.

Manambolo R Butterfly Xxx
Xxx Butterfly
Manambolo R Lizard Cuviers MGSwift
Cuvier's Madagascar Swift

Manambolo R Approaching Village
Approaching the Village of Ankavandra
Manambolo R Ankavandra
Ankavandra

Lova wisely decided we should wait until 14:00 in the cooler afternoon before putting on the river, so we relaxed in the shade on a porch and ordered a soda. Dona was concerned about how she would stay cool in an exposed canoe. We had asked Lova if we could buy an umbrella in Ankavandra and he said yes, so Sid went looking and got one.

We shared some of our trail food with the local kids.

Manambolo R Gary Kids Cherries
Gary Handing Out
Dried Cherries
Photo by Dona
Manambolo R Kids
Kids

Shortly after 14:00 we hiked through the village to the beach, where we had a blessing for a safe trip. We said thanks to our porters, then got in the canoes and shoved off. There were two of us in each boat, a guide and a client, except for Lova whose boat had three. I was paired up with Mami, Dona was paired with Patric, the most experienced and head guide, Sid was with Longi, and Lova was in a boat with Max and a hitch-hiker.

Manambolo R Sid Kids
Sid's Newest Friends

Manambolo R Trail Terrain
Looking back on the Trail

Manambolo R Trip Blessing
Trip Blessing

Manambolo R Porters
Porters

Manambolo R Dona Patric
Dona and Patric

Manambolo R Canoe Sid Longi
Sid and Longi
Photo by Dona

Manambolo R Canoe Gary Mami
Gary and Mami
Photo by Dona

One of the motivations for doing the float was the hope we would see wildlife in a less-disturbed, more natural setting. The scenery along the river was semi-wild and pretty, but not spectacular.

Manambolo R

Manambolo R Bird Purple Heron
Purple Heron
Photo by Dona
Manambolo R Bird Grey Heron
Grey Heron
Photo by Dona

The river is wide, shallow, and muddy. So shallow, in fact, that it was literally difficult to float a boat. Instead of liesurely floating down the river, we spent our entire time on the water weaving back and forth across the river searching for a channel. When we found one, we would try to follow it, but with uniform, muddy water, a channel was impossible to keep track of. In short order we ended up sliding into the sand, grounded on the bottom. We would get out to lessen the draft and push the canoe over the obstacle, or use our paddles as poles to push ourselves through/over it. Or the guides would tell uss to stay put and they would get out and push the boat over the obstruction. It appeared to me there was usually a narrow, < 1m wide channel along the banks, but for some reason the guides seemed to want to find a channel more in the center part of the river; we would be going down the side channel for a while, but then they would head towards the center, and seldom seemed to look back to the shore.

In addition to the river being extremely shallow, the canoes were not well suited to it. They are too short, too narrow, have too much rocker, and too round a bottom. As a result, they ride too low. But they are what the companies have, so they are what they use. However, we were lucky. Other travelers use the native dugout canoes, which are even narrower and ride even lower.

Manambolo R Pushing Canoes
Three days of this gets really tiring

It was still oppressively hot, which made it difficult to enthusiastically do much of anything. While we didn't have to paddle — the guides seemed ok with doing all the paddling — it's not in any of our psyches to sit back and let others do all the work. So even though Dona could have sat back and watched the world go by from under her umbrella, she seldom did. And was unbearably hot as a result.

At one point there was a storm building and I had Dona's rain jacket in my pack, so I tried to get them to pull over so I could give it to her; she got mad at me until she realized what I wanted.

Manambolo R

We camped the first night on a big empty sandbar. The guides spread out a tarp for us to sit on for dinner, which was spaghetti with a chicken leg and broth, with peanuts and "pigeon poop" hors d'oeuvres.

Manambolo R Camp
Camp

Manambolo R Camp
Manambolo R Mosquito Net Tent
Mosquito Net Tent

Manambolo R Max Lova
Max, Lova and a passenger
Manambolo R Dona Sid
Patric and Dona; Longi and Sid

Manambolo R Mami Umbrella Patric
Manambolo R Umbrella Patric

Dona hiding under her Umbrella with Patric
Mami in the back of our Canoe

Unfortunately, the guides didn't speak any English, and maybe not much French; Dona speaks some French but had trouble communicating there too. So it was difficult to know what they wanted us to do to help. Frustratingly, we didn't understand when they would point something out like a bird on the shore until it was too late. When we saw one, we couldn't easily signal "stop" because the guide was behind us. In retrospect, this is a no-brainer; we should have gotten everyone together and worked out some signals we could use. Duh.

Manambolo R Bird Yellow-Billed Kite
Yellow-Billed Kite
Photo by Sid

Manambolo R Bird Peregrine Falcon
Peregrine Falcon
Manambolo R Bird MGPratincole
Madagascar Pratincole
Photo by Dona

Manambolo R Bird MGParadise Flycatcher F
Madagascar
Paradise Flycatcher F
Manambolo R Bird MGMalachite Kingfisher
Madagascar
Malachite Kingfisher
Photo by Sid
Manambolo R Bird Olive Beeeater
Olive Beeeater
Photo by Sid

Manambolo R Bird Purple Heron
Purple Heron
Photo by Dona
Manambolo R Bird Great Egret
Great Egret
Photo by Dona
Manambolo R Bird Xxx
Bird Xxx

Despite communications problems, the guides were great. The fact that they put up with wimpy folks like us speaks well of them. We would stop for lunch around 11:30, and rest up in the shade for a couple of hours. Lunch was always a hot meal based on rice. The guides would start a fire and we would wander around in search of something. Then when the worst of the heat was past, we would put back on the river to paddle down to our next camp.

Manambolo R Lunch
Lunch
Photo by Dona

The river is not "wilderness"; all along the way there are small villages set back from the river where you can't easily see them (except for the last day in the canyon). As we paddled along we would see people on the bank, bathing or fishing or just watching us. Sometimes they would wade part-way out to talk to the guides or make an exchange of some sort; the guides brought a few things down for people they knew who lived along the way and needed something.

Manambolo R
Photo by Dona

Manambolo R People
River People
Photo by Dona
Manambolo R Fisherwomen
Fisherwoman
Manambolo R Young Man
Young Man

Manambolo R Camp
Camp

Manambolo R Storm Clouds
Storm Clouds

Manambolo R Sunset
Sunset

Manambolo R Sunset
Photo by Sid

Manambolo R Camp Sunrise
Manambolo R Camp Sunrise

Sunrise at Camp

Manambolo R Camp Visitors
Camp Visitors from Across the River

We saw only one other recreational group on the river, a large party of French people.

Manambolo R French Camp
The "French" Camp

Dona and I decided one of the classic sounds of Madagascar, besides the Indri, is the Madagascar Coucal. They were a constant presence, like the Howler Monkeys in Guatemala.

Manambolo R Bird MGCoucal
Madagascar Coucal
Manambolo R Bird Black Winged Stilt
Black-Winged Stilt
Manambolo R Bird Great Egret
Great Egret

Manambolo R Bird Striated Heron
Striated Heron
Photo by Sid
Manambolo R Bird Xxx MGPond Heron
Xxx Madagascar Pond Heron
Photo by Dona
Manambolo R Bird Comb Duck
Comb Duck
Photo by Sid

Manambolo R Bird White Faced Whistling Duck
White-Faced Whistling Ducks
Manambolo R Bird White Faced Whistling Duck
Photo by Dona

Manambolo R

Manambolo R Maize Drying
Maize Drying

Camping on the sandbars did not seem ideal. Given the ferocity of the storm on our first night, I didn't relish being on an open sandbar in our flimsy tents in a storm. It was getting late and we were all tired, so when I saw what looked like a great camp sheltered by trees with some grass, I headed for the spot. Mami and I checked it out and it seemed great. Sid and Longi were just getting out when Patric and Dona arrived and Patric told the other guys no, we had to go across and downstream to another big sandbar.

I was miffed; I couldn't understand what was going on. We learned later that Patric is the most respected crocodile hunter on the river, and that the trees and grass along the shore are great nurseries for shrimp and other good things to eat. Crocs love those places. If you don't want crocodiles in camp, you camp on the big open sandbars.

Manambolo R Camp Gary Sid
Gary and Sid at Camp
Photo by Dona

It turns out the Manambolo River has the most crocodiles of any river in Madagascar. If I had known that, I may have been a little more reluctant to go for a dip when we made camp. However, I guess if the crocs don't like the bare sand beaches they probably don't frequent the shallow waters in front of them. In any case, Lova, Sid and I still have all our parts. I tried to convince Dona to get in to cool off but she said she was too tired. Maybe she was also concerned about a cut or scratch getting infected or worried about getting sick somehow.

This was our last night on the river, and it was a hot one. We slept on top of our sleeping sheets and were still hot. The tents were not well vented, but at least they kept the bugs out.

I didn't get any really good bird pictures on the trip, and it was disappointing. But Sid did, so that's good.

Manambolo R Lova Gary Sid
Lova, Gary and Sid
Photo by Dona

Manambolo R Gary
Gary
Photo by Dona
Manambolo R Sid
Sid
Photo by Dona

There were a few birds hanging around camp.

Manambolo R Bird Grey Headed Lovebird
Grey-Headed Lovebirds
Photo by Dona
Manambolo R Bird MGMannikin
Madagascar Mannikin
Photo by Dona
Manambolo R Bird MGSquacco Heron
Malagasy Squacco Heron
Photo by Sid

Manambolo R Flower Xxx White Purple
Flower Xxx White Purple
Photo by Dona

Mangoes are not native to Madagascar, but they thrive there and have been introduced in many places. There were Mango trees all along the river. We picked and ate some on our hike down before we reached Ankavandra, and there were trees laden with fruit overhanging the river.

Manambolo R Mangoes
Mangoes

We paddled up a side channel to stop for lunch. The guys started a fire and cooked up some rice with chicken and vegetables while we rested and took cat-naps. For dessert we had fresh pineapple! Yum!

Lova told us his extra passenger was a guy from Ankavandra hitch-hiking down to Bekopaka to bring his nephew back up. The kid's dad is sick or something and can't do it. So he will help pole the boats back up and bring his nephew with him.

Manambolo R Side Creek
Mami
Manambolo R Side Creek

Side Creek for a Lunch Stop

Some hours later we paddled back to the river. Some families were washing clothes and swimming below us. We surprised a young boy playing by his dugout at the base of a rock bank; he abandoned his canoe and scampered up the rock and disappeared.

Manambolo R

Manambolo R Sid Dona

Our last camp was on a sand bank just inside the canyon. Dinner was spaghetti and duck; Sid's and mine seemed tender enough, but Dona thought hers was a tough. We salted our meals pretty heavily because of the heat; we should have brought some electrolyte drink powder.

Manambolo R Camp
Camp

Manambolo R Camp Pano
Camp

As well as us floating downstream, we saw people poling their dugouts upriver. The current is not too strong, and it's the highway here. But it is slow going and hard work if you're doing it all day or for several days.

Manambolo R Woman Poling Upstream
Woman Poling Upstream

Manambolo R
Manambolo R Cave
Cave

Lova told us there was a cool side canyon we could explore; Sid and I were all for it. We paddled up as far as we could, which wasn't very far. Lova, Longi, Sid and I hiked up to the first big pool. Dona stayed back and looked for birds, butterflies, flowers and other interesting stuff.

Manambolo R Side Canyon
Entering the Side Canyon
Manambolo R Side Canyon
Hiking up the Side Canyon

Manambolo R Side Canyon
Manambolo R Side Canyon

Manambolo R Side Canyon Pool
The Big Pool
Manambolo R Side Canyon Pool Sid
Sid in the Big Pool

Manambolo R Side Canyon Pool Lova
Lova above Chute Feeding the Big Pool
Manambolo R Side Canyon Pool Lova
Lova

Manambolo R Side Canyon Pool
Manambolo R Side Canyon Pool
Longi and Sid

Manambolo R Plated Lizard
Plated Lizard

The Tsingy formations are immediately north of the river here; I found a "micro tsingy" forming in the limestone around the pool.

Manambolo R Tsingy
Manambolo R Tsingy

Tsingy just starting out

When we got back to the boats we found Dona had tracked down some cool dragonflies.

Manambolo R Flower Xxx Purple
Flower Xxx Purple
Manambolo R Flower Xxx Blue
Flower Xxx Blue

Manambolo R Bug Dragon Fly Xxx Orange Blue
Dragonfly Xxx Orange Blue
Photo by Dona
Manambolo R Bug Dragonfly Xxx Xparent
Dragonfly Xxx Transparent
Photo by Dona
Manambolo R Bug Dragonfly Xxx Gold
Dragonfly Xxx Gold
Photo by Dona
Manambolo R Bug Dragonfly Xxx Blue
Dragonfly Xxx Blue
Photo by Dona

Manambolo R Tree Flower Xxx Yellow
Tree Flower Xxx Yellow
Photo by Dona

Manambolo R Side Canyon
Heading Back to the Main River

We got back in the boats and headed out to the main river. We found a man chopping out a new dugout on the bank.

Manambolo R Building Dugout
Man Building a Dugout
Manambolo R Man Poling Dugout
Man Poling Dugout

Manambolo R Side Cr
Side Creek

We stopped for lunch under a big shady overhang. We watched a woman building a shrimp fishing "trap". She jammed poles into the river bottom and then wove branches with lots of leaves on them around the poles. Apparently the shrimp congregate in these places, and the people can come back with a net to harvest them. However, the crocodiles are also probably attracted to those shrimp...

Manambolo R Lunch Stop
Lunch Stop
Manambolo R Butterfly Spotted Blue Swallowtail
Spotted Blue Swallowtail

Manambolo R Man Poling Upstream
Woman Poling Upstream
Manambolo R Canoe Young Girl Boy
Young Woman Poling Boy in Canoe
Photo by Dona

Manambolo R Shrimp Trap
Shrimp Trap

After lunch we headed back down river. We passed many interesting eroded limestone formations along the way,

Manambolo R
Manambolo R

Manambolo R Dona Sid Patric Longi
Dona, Sid, Patric and Longi

Manambolo R
Manambolo R

The Insignificance of Man

And then we were at the take out. We piled ashore, and Caesar was there to meet us. He had driven back out the way we went in, then all the way around to Bekopaka. We were delighted to see his cheery face.

Manambolo R Ferry
Ferry at the Take Out

Manambolo R Take Out
Take Out

Manambolo R Crew Longi Max Mami Patric Lova
Longi, Max, Mami, Patric, Lova
Manambolo R Crew Longi Max Mami Patric Lova
Longi, Max, Gary, Mami, Patric,
Dona, Lova, Sid
Photo by Caesar with Sid's Camera

Lova told us this was the first trip for these guys this year, so a tough year. He expected it would be the only trip, since the rains had started and once the rains hit, the roads to Bekopa, the take-out, become impassable. They usually each get about six trips. There are about 80 guides at Ankavandra and they rotate guiding; some didn't get any trips this year.

Manambolo R

Our guides would spend the next few days relaxing and spending money in Bekopaka, much like miners or cowboys after a payday. Then they would load their boats with supplies they had bought and pole them back up the river.

Dona's phone didn't work after we got off the river. We hypothesized it had gotten too hot sitting in an outside pocket of her suitcase on top on the boat.